Tuesday, November 1, 2016

Where We Are

You know, I update my lock screen on my computer to really the player of the game or defining play from a win.  I’m sort of tired of looking at Sony vs. South Carolina.
 
How in the world did we get to 4-4?  How in the world do we get out of this hole?  After a few days, a few things are clear.
 
·       A performance like this always brings out the yahoos.  This morning Steak Shapiro had the yahoo come out in him, suggesting that he’s disappointed in Eason and that he hasn’t developed.  What in the world is he watching?  It felt like a comment bashing Bobo back in the day.  A caller blasted him on it.  Jake is the least of our problems.  The Florida coach knows it, too.  Speaking of Bobo, remember when we’d all complain about this play call or that play call after we’d scored 35 points?  Fun times.
·       This is life with a true freshman QB.  It just is, unless you are supremely loaded in other areas.  I’ve seen us start a few of them, and I’ve learned my lesson.  We were 6-7 with Aaron Murray, and he had a junior AJ Green to throw to the last 2/3 of the season.  We still lost to an awful Colorado team.  We still lost to Central Florida and did not score a TD in the game.  I saw us start Matt Stafford in a season and lost to Vandy and Kentucky in 1 season.  And we darn near lost to that same terrible Colorado team, too.  In 2001, we Greenie had Terrance Edwards, Fred Gibson and Reggie Brown in his 3 WR set, and George Foster and Jon Stinchcomb at tackles, and Boss Bailey and Tony Gilbert at LB, Charles Grant at DE.  We didn’t need David to do much, but he did enough.  We still lost 4 games.  Bottom line is that even Richt and Bobo, the QB whisperers, struggled with Freshmen QBs (and even first year starters, to some extent). 
·       I’m incredibly frustrated by Chaney.  I listened to Kirby’s presser today, and I sense he is, too.  But, I keep coming back to Kyle Shanahan.  He was awful with the Falcons last year, and they couldn’t score.  1 center (Alex Mack) and 1 year later, and they’re the best offense in the league, and Matt Ryan might win the MVP.  An offensive lineman and a season can go a long way.  Kirby doesn’t do much w/ the O.  He’s going to let an OC run the show.  That means if we bring in a new guy, we’re going to have seniors learning new terminology for the 4th time in 4 years.  I really, really, really, really don’t want to have to fire him.  I also don’t know who we’d get.  Randy Sanders at FSU, maybe?  BTW, it’s clear that Richt made the mistake that cost him his job with Schotty.  Clemson lost Chad Morris put replaced him with insiders and kept the same system. 
·       I’m not sure the ADs care because they’re counting their money from the city of Jax, but we need to rethink that thing.  There were a lot of empty seats on both sides.  We had probably 6 next to us and others around us that never filled.  I think, culturally, every year it has become a grind.  I contend that jax-athens-jax-gainesville would be great.  Every senior would get a home game, a road game and get to play in jax twice.
 
We are in a terrible predicament, and frankly have been.  It’s so easy for fans outside the program or even fringe UGA fans to scoff now because we fired a coach that had won 10 games.  It was, painfully, time.  We wouldn’t have signed Ridley or Simmons at WR.  We wouldn’t have signed Herrien or David Marshall.  We wouldn’t have Mo Smith.  We’d have Bailey Hockman committed at QB and not Jake Fromm.
 
My immediate concern is that we’re no fun at all right now.  We’ve been a hard team to watch for a season and a half.  The last time we all felt really, really good was vs. South Carolina last year.  We felt good vs. UNC this year, but it was so short lived.  It’s just a painful bunch to watch.  We desperately need something fun to happen with the team.  That goes without saying.  A great showing in a victory vs. what will be a top-10 Auburn team would go a long way for the team.
 
My longer term concern is that it’s going to take a while to fix our O-line, like at least till 2018.  I’m wondering if we’re going to go after a JUCO tackle.  As bad as it is, one great tackle would make a world of difference.  An offensive line is like a basketball team.  You don’t need 5 stars.  You need 2 stars (that can handle one on one and dominate), and 3 guys to play their roles.
 
I’m also wondering if we’re going to see some transfers after the season.  It’s just a bad spot to be.  We had to make a change.  I think we made the right change.  There is no magic bullet.  Herman looks like he’s still learning on the job and would have completely overhauled our system and has no experience in Southern culture.  But this was just going to happen.  Donnan went 5-6 then went 10-2 the next year.  Richt went 8-4 then 13-1.  
 
Donnan had Auburn ’96.  Richt had Tennessee and Tech ’01.  Kirby could sure use Auburn and Tech ’16.

5 comments:

  1. "It’s so easy for fans outside the program or even fringe UGA fans to scoff now because we fired a coach that had won 10 games"

    So, in your opinion, UGA fans that scoff at the decision to fire CMR or to hire the inexperienced CKS is simply a "Fringe UGA Fan". You are some kind of delusional. The Vocal Minority wanted CMR fired. An even smaller minority wanted CKS hired.

    "I think we made the right change"

    Of course. Why not. Because CKS coached with Saban, right? He sat at the feet of greatness and learned the secret of the Process. Right? Right? Obviously it worked well for Derek Dooley. And Will Muschamp. And Jim McElwain. Here's some facts that might help.
    - No Saban assistant has ever beaten him head to head.
    - First year HC's cutting their teeth for the first time in the SEC haven't fared well at all in modern times with the exception of CMR.
    - Saban assistants as HC's in the SEC haven't fared well.
    - While Kirby hasn't had his signature win or even play yet, he has allowed other firsts....
    - Derek Mason picks up his SEC road win.
    - We had the worst offensive output in series history vs. Flordia
    - We were defeated by the worst margin in series history to what has turned out to be a pedestrian Ole Miss squad.
    - We had the smallest victory margin over a D1-AA team in recent memory.
    - We are digressing as a team as the season moves on.

    So how exactly was Kirby the right choice? Considering first year HC's in the modern era don't work out well in the SEC. Of course, with the exception of CMR. Why not go after an experienced HC that wins. And if one isn't available, why move now? Why not wait until one becomes available? Because facts are irrelevant.

    And Kirby goes out and hires two men that served in their same capacities with Derek Dooley while he burned UT to the ground. Way to go, Kirbster.

    But what do I know? I'm just a 7th generation Georgian that lived through Dooley, Goff & Donnan prior to Richt. I'm just a fringe fan. There can't possibly be more that feel the way I do.

    This fringe fan feels that fans such as yourself are where the full blame lies. Fans that spend so much time wishing they were Alabama, they'll sacrifice reason and facts for the mirage that they just know to be true. Thanks for our new reality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The only mirage is believing you can consistently win in the SEC with a complete lack of attention and recruiting of top linemen on both sides. Richt's best years were from 02-05 with mostly Jim Donnan's recruits in the trenches. Since then we have fielded a truely competitive team twice, and those teams never made it to the promised land because they laid an inexplicable egg in one or more games each year. You know why? It's going to happen when you depend that highly on skill guys to win football games. You know why Alabama and LSU have been so consistent in the West? DOMINATING O & D Lines. That is what Kirby is instilling at UGA. It takes time. I can't wait to hear how that crow tastes in a couple of years.

      Delete
    2. Eason was a solid CMR recruit. He only had second thoughts when CMR was fired. I bet a ten win season would be looking really good about now.

      Delete
  2. Going after JC players to step in and play is as big a stretch at OT as sticking true Freshman out there. The grad transfer hasnt worked out and he was well thought of so why would a JC player be better.
    I agree with One thing you said. It was time for Richt to move on not because he was a bad coach or anything else in my mind he had became stagnant and at this level if you have stopped moving forward then you start taking steps backwards as programs around you improve.
    2018? Team has averaged 9 wins a year for a decade and a half with the same level talent it currently has ...... If it takes him till 2018 to win then we will never win at UGA under Smart just like the idiot TN fans listening to there coach talk about building brick by brick and this year they were suppose to be challengers guess what.....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think good ole Booch at UT is a few bricks short in that spectacular rebuilding. I'm a Dawg that lives in Tennessee. It was obvious from the get-go that they were smoke & mirrors. It's all hitting the fan agin in Knoxville. The radio here is Nashville is some quality meltdown.

      Delete